Do u think Judge Judy could be the next American Idol Judge?

LOL - Sure... she's so experienced in the Music Business. NOT!! Even if she actually had any connection to the music business... she'd annoy the crap out of most. Her voice alone would make me turn the channel... not that Ryan Seacrest doesn't make we want to do that anyway. Simon could be annoying sometimes, but he was usually right. Why? Because he's in the business of finding talent, owns a record label. Started from the bottom in the mail room in his fathers music publishing company and worked his way up. Then started his own business. It doesn't get more experienced and knowledgeable, OR more qualified to have been doing what he did for/on American Idol, than that. I can't imagine who could fill those shoes. Chances are it won't be anyone close to the quality of a Simon Cowell.